Low Commission REALTORS® vs Traditional Agents in Edmonton - The Black Sheep Difference.

(Real Estate, Reinvented: More Value, Less Commission.)

Why the Traditional Commission Model Is Broken — And How a 1% Listing Solves It

If you’ve landed on this page, chances are you’re thinking about selling your home. And you’ve started to realize there’s more than one way to pay a real estate agent.

You’ve probably heard the terms “low commission,” “1% REALTOR®,” or maybe even stumbled across us by name. And if you’re like most sellers, you may be wondering:

“What’s the actual difference between a traditional agent and a low commission one? And what do I actually get for that extra fee?”

You’re not alone. Real estate commissions are notoriously confusing. It's a topic full of vague explanations and outdated justifications.

At Black Sheep Realty, we aim to cut through the fluff. Our mission is simple:

Deliver everything you’d expect from a top-tier, full-service brokerage at a fraction of the cost.

We don’t cut corners. Just commissions.

We’re confident in what we offer: marketing, negotiations, listings, photography, guidance, support, and everything in between. We do what traditional agents do (often more), for thousands less.

But we get it. That sounds like marketing talk. So let’s dig deeper.

This article answers the most common questions we get from sellers just like you:

  • What’s the actual difference in service?
  • Where does the commission go?
  • How can you charge less and still offer more?
  • Is low commission right for every seller?

No pressure. No sales pitch. Just clear info so you can decide what fits you best.

Wondering what your home is worth?

Contact us for a free home valuation!

What marketing is included?

In short, we consistently provide an extremely high level of marketing for every property we list.


Regardless of price point or area, our clients receive the full range of marketing services for their home. In our 1% package, this includes:

  • REALTOR.ca and MLS® exposure
  • Up to 50 professional photos
  • Dedicated organic social media campaigns
  • Traditional marketing such as lawn signs and key safes for easy showings


At Black Sheep Realty, our philosophy is simple: no BS. Do what works to sell a home, and charge homeowners a fee model that makes sense.


Not only do we provide a high level of marketing and service for a fraction of the cost, but a major point of pride for our brokerage is that we offer a clearly defined and consistent listing package.


Every home we list receives the same core marketing support, regardless of:

  • Price
  • Style
  • Location
  • Neighbourhood


No matter what you are selling, you receive the type of marketing you would expect to see on HGTV-style real estate shows.


By contrast, some other brokerages adjust their marketing based on sale price, home type, or location.

Marketing Comparison Summary

Black Sheep Realty:

  • Consistent marketing and service for every home
  • Clearly defined listing package
  • Higher levels of marketing and service than many traditional brokerages
  • High-end marketing tools such as professional photography and organic social media content


Traditional Agents:

  • No guaranteed level of marketing
  • No standardized listing packages
  • Marketing may fluctuate based on list price
  • May not offer professional photos, video, or social media campaigns, even at higher price points

Is My Home on the Association’s MLS® System? What About REALTOR.ca?

Fair question, and the answer is a resounding yes.


Will your home be on the Association’s MLS® System? Yes.


Will it be on REALTOR.ca? Yes.


Are they the same thing? Kind of.


Technically, that’s the end of this section, and you could skip to the next one. However, if you are curious about how the MLS® system actually works, it is worth clearing up a few common misconceptions:


“There’s No Secret Sauce”

One line we share with almost all of our clients is:


“There’s no secret sauce.”


All REALTORS® across Canada have access to the same Multiple Listing Service®, and the same centralized data feed that powers REALTOR.ca.


No brokerage has special access. No company has a hidden database. No one gets “extra” exposure.

How REALTOR.ca and the MLS® System Works

Without getting too technical, here is how it works in simple terms:


Each city’s MLS® system is administered by the local real estate board


All local MLS® systems feed into a centralized national database


That centralized feed powers REALTOR.ca


REALTOR.ca then feeds into most major home search websites


Because of this structure, nearly every real estate website in Canada is showing the same listings from the same source.

Why All Listings Appear Everywhere

There can be some confusion because there are so many home search websites.


However, they are all pulling from the same feed.


When you look at REALTOR.ca, you are seeing all active listings on the market. Other platforms simply display that same data in different formats.


There is no “premium” feed. There is no upgraded tier. There is no hidden distribution network.

What This Means for Black Sheep Clients

When you list with Black Sheep Realty, your home is placed on:


The Association’s MLS® System


REALTOR.ca


And thousands of connected home search websites in the Edmonton area


Your listing receives the same baseline exposure as any traditional brokerage.


In fact, the efficiency and transparency of Canada’s listing infrastructure is part of what allows companies like ours to operate at a lower cost in the first place.

Exposure Comparison Summary

Black Sheep Realty:

  • Your listing appears on the Association’s MLS® System
  • Your listing appears on REALTOR.ca
  • Your listing is syndicated to major home search platforms


Traditional Agents:

  • Your listing appears on the Association’s MLS® System
  • Your listing appears on REALTOR.ca
  • Your listing is syndicated to major home search platforms

The bottom line:
There is only one primary listing feed in Canada. All licensed agents access the same system. Your home appears in the same places regardless of who you list with.

What If I Need Help? What Kind of Service Do I Receive?

We are a full-service real estate brokerage, meaning we provide 100 percent of the service you should expect from any traditional real estate agent.


Our consistent listing package ensures that we deliver a high level of service across every property we list. More importantly, you do not have to do anything yourself.


From start to finish, we guide you through the entire process.


Local Agents With Direct Access

We are local agents with boots on the ground in Edmonton.


You do not have to call a 1-800 number or navigate a call centre to reach someone. You receive our direct work cell numbers and speak with the people actually handling your transaction.


This also differs from sell-by-owner models and some low commission companies, where sellers may be responsible for:

  • Arranging showings
  • Coordinating access
  • Following up with agents
  • Gathering feedback


With us, that responsibility stays with our team.

Our Showing and Feedback System

We actively seek feedback from every showing.


While not every buyer’s agent provides feedback, when it is available, we share it with you and use it to guide pricing, presentation, and strategy.


Typically, we make two to three attempts to collect feedback after each showing. Speaking purely from experience, this is often more than what many higher-cost agents consistently do.


This process helps ensure you are informed and supported throughout the listing period.

Service Comparison Summary

Black Sheep Realty:

  • Proven showing and feedback systems
  • Local, active agents
  • Direct contact and personalized service
  • Seven-day-a-week availability


Traditional Agents:

  • May require seller involvement in showings
  • Centralized phone systems
  • Inconsistent feedback processes
  • Less standardized follow-up

How Much Will I Save?

The amount you save depends on the final sale price of your home.


In most cases, our low commission plans save sellers:

  • Around 50 percent on the listing commission side, and
  • Approximately 25 to 30 percent on total commission,
    when compared to traditional 7/3 brokerages.


For a visual breakdown, you can also view our commission calculator page.


By contrast, some other brokerages adjust their marketing based on sale price, home type, or location.

Commission Savings Comparison Summary

Black Sheep Realty:

  • Approximately 50 percent listing-side commission savings compared to 3.5/1.5 fee models on the average-priced home in Edmonton and surrounding areas
  • Significant savings across most price points


Traditional Agents:

  • Many brokerages still charge the same 7/3 commission model and do not typically waive it
  • No guaranteed savings or standardized reduced-fee plans
  • Negotiation may be possible, but outcomes vary

What About Buyer’s Agents? Do You Have Full Cooperation From Other Agents and Brokerages?

This is one of the biggest questions sellers have, and it is an important one.


The short answer is: yes, we have full cooperation with other brokerages.


Why?


Because we consistently recommend offering a competitive cooperating commission to the buyer’s agent.

Why Cooperation Matters

Offering a fair cooperating commission is part of our philosophy of giving you the most honest and practical advice possible.


Some companies promise additional savings by reducing or limiting buyer-agent commissions. In reality, these savings are:

  • Not guaranteed
  • Often ineffective
  • Sometimes detrimental to your sale


In many cases, restricting buyer-agent compensation reduces showing activity and interest, which can ultimately hurt your final sale price.


Our priority is always to help you achieve the best overall outcome, not just the lowest possible fee on paper.

How Buyers Actually Think

Our marketing is focused on attracting buyers and showcasing your property.


At the end of the day, buyers care about:

  • The home
  • The price
  • The location
  • The layout
  • Whether it fits their needs


They generally do not care who the listing agent is.


Strong exposure, professional presentation, and competitive positioning are what drive interest and offers, not internal commission structures.

Cooperation Comparison Summary

Black Sheep Realty:

  • Full cooperation with other brokerages
  • Competitive buyer-agent compensation recommendations
  • Strong relationships within the local real estate community


Traditional Agents:

  • Some low-fee or FSBO models may encourage reduced buyer-agent commissions, even when it may negatively impact the sale
  • Traditional brokerages typically offer full cooperation

Is There Anything You Do Differently Than a Traditional 7/3 Agent?

In theory, no.


In practice, we often do more than many agents at traditional brokerages.


Why?


Because our business model is consistent and scalable. That allows us to invest in better systems, stronger marketing, and more comprehensive support, while delivering that same high standard of service to every client.


Rather than relying on high individual commissions, we focus on efficiency, volume, and process. This enables us to provide:

  • More consistent service
  • More advanced marketing
  • Better operational support
  • A smoother overall experience
  • for every seller we represent.


Our goal is not to cut corners. It is to deliver a better version of full-service real estate.

Ready to See What Your Home Could Sell For?


If you are considering selling your home and would like to understand:

  • What your home is worth in today’s market
  • How much you could save in commissions
  • What our marketing plan would look like for your property


We invite you to contact us for a free, no-obligation home valuation.


Our consultations are always complimentary, and we are happy to walk you through your options so you can make the best decision for your situation.

About Black Sheep

At Black Sheep, our philosophy is simple; No BS. Do what works to sell a home and charge home sellers a fee model that makes sense.


Our goal is straightforward; to help you sell your property, have a smooth and positive selling experience, and help you net more from the sale of your property.


We strive to be just what the name implies; the Black Sheep of the industry. Those who go against the grain, stand out from the crowd, and are juuust a little different from the rest, all with the end goal of pushing the real estate business in a positive direction.